Skip to main content

Breaking Down the Cost of an In-House Accountant

Published 1st December 2023
In this article
Share this article with others

Breaking Down the Cost of an In-House Accountant

Published 1st December 2023

In today's business landscape, where fiscal prudence and strategic resource allocation are top priorities, comprehending the true cost of an in-house accountant extends beyond salary figures. It encompasses recruitment expenses, benefits, technology investments, and the broader implications of talent acquisition. This blog will equip you with a comprehensive perspective, empowering you to make informed decisions regarding your accounting needs. 

Key Takeaways
  • Comprehensive Costs: Understanding the true cost of an in-house accountant requires considering salaries, benefits, office space, supplies, and software licenses.
  • Investment in Time: The time and resources spent on training, onboarding, and retention are significant investments beyond direct financial costs.
  • Hidden Expenses: Overtime, holiday pay, and recruitment process costs are often overlooked but can significantly affect the overall budget.
  • Risk Management: Employers must be vigilant about potential fraud and errors, adopting strategies like segregation of duties and regular audits to protect their interests.
  • Scalability and Flexibility: As businesses grow, they must decide between expanding in-house teams or outsourcing to adapt to increasing financial demands.

The Financial Aspect Investment

Salaries and Benefits

An in-house accountant's salary varies based on experience, location, and industry specialisation. Benefits like health insurance, retirement contributions, and bonuses are essential for talent retention. Offering competitive benefits may raise hiring costs but boosts job satisfaction and lowers turnover rates, benefiting the organisation long-term. 

Operating Costs

Operating costs related to an in-house accountant encompass a range of expenses that may not be immediately apparent. It's essential to account for these costs when evaluating the overall financial investment.

Office Space and Supplies

Office space is a substantial cost, especially in metropolitan areas. Accountants require a dedicated workspace equipped with the necessary tools, such as computers, printers, and accounting software. In addition to rent or lease expenses, office supplies like stationery, paper, and pens can add up over time.

Software Licences

Accounting software is essential for in-house accountants but can incur substantial licensing, updates, and maintenance fees. Comprehending these costs is vital for budgeting and making informed decisions. This knowledge empowers employers and agencies to plan for financial commitments while supporting the accountant's effectiveness.

Time and Human Resources

When breaking down the costs of an in-house accountant, it's vital to consider the investment in time and human resources, factors that often go beyond monetary figures but are equally significant.

Training and Onboarding

Training and onboarding a new in-house accountant require a considerable investment of time and resources. This process includes introducing the accountant to the company's culture, policies, and procedures, as well as providing training on specific accounting systems and processes. The duration of this phase can vary depending on the accountant's prior experience and familiarity with the company's operations.

Employee Turnover and Retention

Employee turnover can be costly, with recruitment and training expenses for replacements. It disrupts workflow, affecting productivity and possibly causing financial reporting errors or delays. Strategies like career development and a positive work environment can reduce turnover and costs. Understanding time and human resource investments underscores efficient training and retention as key factors in minimising costs and maximising the accountant's contributions.

Hidden Costs

While the direct expenses of an in-house accountant, such as salaries and benefits, may be evident, there are hidden costs that employers and recruitment agency clients should consider when evaluating the overall investment. Two significant hidden costs are overtime and holiday pay, as well as recruitment expenses.

in house accountant image1

Overtime and Holiday Pay

Accounting responsibilities often follow strict deadlines, such as month-end or year-end financial closings. During these periods, in-house accountants may need to work overtime to meet reporting requirements. Overtime pay, including any additional benefits like holiday pay, can significantly impact the budget.

Additionally, holidays and vacation days are part of the employment package. When an in-house accountant takes time off, whether planned or unplanned, there may be a need for temporary staffing or redistribution of workload, incurring extra costs.

Recruitment Costs

The process of hiring an in-house accountant involves various expenses, including advertising job openings, conducting interviews, and screening candidates. Recruitment agencies may also charge fees for their services. Moreover, there's a potential cost associated with time spent by existing employees in the hiring process.

By acknowledging these hidden costs and implementing strategies to manage them effectively, employers can gain a more accurate understanding of the total financial commitment associated, enabling informed decision-making and budget planning.

Risk Factors: Fraud and Errors

Understanding these risk factors is essential for employers. Here are common types of fraud and errors that may affect the cost considerations of an in-house accountant, along with mitigation strategies:

Common Types of Fraud

  • Embezzlement: Misappropriation of company funds by the accountant.
  • Invoice Fraud: Manipulating invoices for personal gain.
  • Falsifying Records: Altering financial documents to conceal discrepancies.

Mitigation Strategies

  • Segregation of Duties: Divide financial responsibilities among multiple employees.
  • Regular Audits: Conduct routine financial audits to identify irregularities.
  • Fraud Training: Provide anti-fraud training to employees.
  • Use of Accounting Software: Implement accounting software with audit trails.

Errors, although not necessarily malicious, can also lead to financial losses. These may include data entry mistakes, calculation errors, or inaccuracies in financial reporting. Mitigation strategies involve thorough reviews, reconciliations, and the use of software tools to minimise the likelihood of errors. By addressing the risks associated with fraud and errors, employers and recruitment agency clients can safeguard their financial interests while employing an in-house accountant.

Contingency Plans: What Happens When Your Accountant Is Unavailable?

Employers and recruitment agency clients must anticipate scenarios where their in-house accountants may be unavailable due to illness, leave, or unforeseen circumstances. Here's how to prepare:

Backup Plans

  • Establish clear backup accountancy procedures.
  • Identify qualified employees who can step in temporarily.
  • Ensure that critical financial documentation is accessible to authorised staff.

Temporary Staffing

  • Consider temporary or interim accounting professionals.
  • Leverage the expertise of accounting agencies for short-term support.
  • Maintain open lines of communication with temporary staff to facilitate a smooth transition.

By having well-defined backup plans and temporary staffing strategies in place, businesses can mitigate disruptions in financial operations when their in-house accountant is unavailable, ensuring financial stability and compliance.

Scalability: Adapting to Business Growth

As businesses evolve and grow, their financial needs expand accordingly. The ability to adapt the accounting function to these changing demands is paramount.

When to Hire More Staff

One essential aspect of scalability is recognising the right time to hire additional in-house accountants. Monitoring workloads and assessing employee performance can provide crucial insights. If existing staff consistently grapple with heavy workloads, leading to missed deadlines or increased errors, it may be a sign that it's time to expand the team. 

Outsourcing as a Scalable Option

Another viable approach to scalability is outsourcing. During periods of high demand, outsourcing certain accounting functions can alleviate the burden on in-house staff. Specialised accounting agencies can be engaged to handle specific tasks or projects, providing flexibility and expertise. It's essential to evaluate the cost-effectiveness of outsourcing compared to hiring more staff, as this decision should align with the company's financial strategy.

At Macildowie, we can help you strategically determine when to hire additional staff and explore outsourcing options to ensure continued efficiency and compliance with financial requirements as your organisation grows and evolves.

Comparing Costs: In-House vs. Outsourced Accounting

Choosing between in-house and outsourced accounting solutions is a pivotal decision for any organisation. Both options offer distinct advantages and cost considerations that necessitate careful evaluation.

In-House Accounting

Maintaining an in-house accounting team provides direct control and accessibility. However, this approach entails costs beyond salaries and benefits, such as office space, software licenses, and ongoing training. It's essential to consider the cumulative expenses associated with recruiting, onboarding, and retaining employees. Employee turnover and its associated costs can further impact the budget. Additionally, hidden costs like overtime and holiday pay can escalate expenditures.

Outsourced Accounting

Outsourcing accounting can cut costs on benefits, training, and office space while providing access to skilled experts. However, pricing and contracts differ among providers, so a detailed analysis is necessary. The choice between in-house and outsourcing should align with your financial strategy and business objectives, ensuring optimal efficiency and goal support.

Evaluating Outsourced Accounting for Small Business Owners

For small business owners, managing the day-to-day accounting work can be time-consuming and may detract from core business operations. It's critical to explore whether hiring a full-time employee or engaging with outsourced accounting services can save time and money in the long run.

The Value of Outsourced Accounting Services

Outsourced accounting firms offer a practical alternative, providing a spectrum of services from managing daily transactions to preparing financial statements. By outsourcing, business owners can focus on growing their business, knowing that the financial aspects are in expert hands.

Cost Benefits for Small Businesses

Outsourcing accounting functions can be particularly cost-effective for small businesses. Without the need to hire a full-time employee, businesses can save on salary, benefits, and the overhead associated with maintaining an in-house team. This can be a strategic move to optimise financial resources.

Choosing the Right Accounting Firm

When considering outsourced accounting services, it’s important to choose a firm that understands the unique challenges of small businesses. The right firm should help business owners make informed decisions, anticipate financial challenges, and position the business for growth.


In the ever-evolving landscape of financial management, understanding the multifaceted costs of an in-house accountant is crucial for prudent decision-making. By breaking down the intricacies of these expenditures, we empower employers and clients with insights to navigate this financial commitment effectively. 

At Macildowie, we recognise the significance of optimising your accounting team while mitigating costs. Our recruitment expertise and network of skilled financial professionals enable us to tailor solutions that align with your unique needs. Whether you choose in-house or outsourced accounting, our commitment to excellence ensures that your financial team thrives. Partner with Macildowie to streamline your recruitment process and access top accounting talent that will drive your business forward.


What factors should we consider when budgeting for an in-house accountant?

When budgeting for an in-house accountant, consider salary, benefits, recruitment costs, office space, supplies, software licences, training, and potential overtime expenses. A comprehensive budget ensures transparency in cost analysis.

How can we mitigate the risk of fraud and errors, which can result in additional costs?

Mitigate the risk of fraud and errors by implementing internal controls, conducting regular audits, and promoting a culture of compliance. Investing in technology and employee training can also enhance error prevention.

Is it cost-effective to hire temporary staff as a contingency plan for accountant unavailability?

Hiring temporary staff as a contingency plan can be cost-effective, especially for short-term gaps. However, having backup plans and cross-training existing employees can minimise the need for temporary staffing.

When should we consider expanding our in-house accounting team to accommodate business growth?

Expansion should be considered when the workload consistently exceeds the capacity of your current team, leading to inefficiencies. Evaluate the feasibility of outsourcing before hiring more staff to ensure scalability.

What are the advantages of comparing in-house and outsourced accounting costs?

Comparing in-house and outsourced accounting costs helps in making informed decisions. Outsourcing can offer cost savings, flexibility, and access to a broader skill set, while in-house teams provide more control and immediate accessibility. Weigh the pros and cons to determine the best fit for your organisation.

Streamline Your Financial Recruitment
When the costs and complexities of managing an in-house accounting team seem overwhelming, it's time to consider a specialised recruitment partner. Macildowie offers a robust solution for your accounting and finance staffing needs, providing expert guidance to ensure you find the perfect fit for your organisation—be it temporary, interim, or permanent roles.